Tata Sierra EV vs MG Windsor EV: Which EV Makes More Sense On Paper?

After being announced more than five years before, the Tata Sierra EV has finally been introduced in the market as a direct rival to the likes of the Hyundai Creta Electric and Maruti Suzuki e Vitara. Given its price and positioning, the Sierra EV also takes on one of the best-selling electric cars in India, namely, the MG Windsor EV. In this story, we have put the Tata Sierra EV and MG Windsor EV head-to-head to see which one comes out on top, at least on paper:

Tata Sierra EV vs MG Windsor EV: Dimensions

•  The Tata Sierra EV is bigger than the MG Windsor EV in all aspects, save for the overall width, where it falls short by a marginal 9 mm.

• The biggest advantage comes in the form of the additional length, height and wheelbase, all of which are likely to make the Sierra EV a slightly roomier affair inside the cabin.

Tata Sierra EV vs MG Windsor EV: Colour Options

•  While MG offers its EV in six paint options, the Sierra EV is available in a total of seven unique colourways.

• That said, neither of the two all-electric offerings here get the choice of a dual-tone exterior paint shade.

• We've already covered the complete range of colours available across Tata Sierra EV variants to help you choose the one that best suits your taste.

Tata Sierra EV vs MG Windsor EV: Features

•  Both Tata and MG have loaded their EVs with plenty of modern-age tech, such as all-LED lighting, a big touchscreen, six airbags (as standard) and Level-2 ADAS as well.

• That said, the Sierra EV does have its own advantages, including glove box cooling, a co-driver entertainment screen, and front and rear parking sensors.

• The MG Windsor EV, on the other hand, gets 135-degree reclining rear seats, 256-colours ambient lighting, a powered tailgate, and a larger 15.6-inch touchscreen infotainment system.

• You can check out the full variant-wise features list of the Tata Sierra EV to make an informed purchase decision.

Tata Sierra EV vs MG Windsor EV: Electric Powertrain

*RWD - rear-wheel drive, AWD - all-wheel drive, FWD - front-wheel drive

• Both the EVs here come with two battery pack options, although those with the Sierra EV are larger in capacity.

• It’s also the Tata electric SUV that gets the choice of an AWD setup, whereas the Windsor EV is an FWD offering only.

• When the output of the electric powertrains is considered, the Sierra EV wins the battle in both its electric powertrain setups.

• Even the claimed range figures of the Sierra EV are higher than those of the MG Windsor EV that is likely to appeal to a wider set of potential buyers.

• You can also check out the full variant-wise powertrains on offer with the Tata Sierra EV to pick the right powertrain setup for your needs. 

Tata Sierra EV vs MG Windsor EV: Prices

All prices are ex-showroom, pan-India

•  The MG Windsor EV has a much lower access point when compared to that of the Tata Sierra EV, amounting up to Rs 4.69 lakh.

• Even at the top-end, the corresponding variants of both the EVs are separated by a price difference of nearly Rs 7.5 lakh.

• Out of the two, it’s only the MG Windsor EV that is also available with the Battery-as-a-Service (BaaS) option, which makes its prices fall between Rs 9.99 lakh and Rs 13.39 lakh (coupled with the battery rental fee).

CarDekho Says…

The Tata Sierra EV is the most modern all-electric offering you can have from the Indian brand, and it is packed with the latest technology and a potent set of electric powertrains. An AWD setup, claimed range figures of over 500 km, and a feature-rich cabin experience are promising enough to attract many potential EV buyers.

On the other hand, the MG Windsor EV has also proven its mettle and has also been ranked at the top in monthly sales quite frequently. That’s down to its unique traits such as some exclusive premium amenities, the choice of two electric powertrains, and also the BaaS option. Pick either of the two and you won’t go wrong.

Other Options To Consider

If the Sierra EV and Windsor EV are on your shortlist, here are some other electric SUVs that deserve a closer look:

• Hyundai Creta Electric: Offers a familiar SUV package with a plethora of features and Hyundai’s reliability.

• Maruti e Vitara: Maruti’s first-ever EV offers a high claimed range, along with an extensive set of features and a well-covered safety package.

• VinFast VF7: Stands out with its clean and modern styling, impressive fit and finish, and offers a choice of two electric powertrain options.

• VinFast VF6: The smaller brother of the VF7 offers the premium cabin experience but in a smaller footprint and a smaller price tag in comparison to the VF7.

• Toyota Urban Cruiser Ebella: Brings sharp styling, a premium cabin, a smooth driving experience, and a feature-loaded package.

• MG ZS EV: Offers a premium cabin, a well-equipped feature list, and enough range to comfortably handle everyday driving. Our detailed comparison of the Sierra EV and ZS EV should make the buying decision easier for you between these two electric SUVs.

• Mahindra BE 6: Grabs attention with its futuristic styling, while backing it up with strong performance, impressive real-world range, and one of the best infotainment experiences in the segment. We have compared the two to help you buy the one that best suits your needs.