MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch
Should you buy MG Comet EV or Tata Punch? Find out which car is best for you - compare the two models on the basis of their Price, Size, Space, Boot Space, Service cost, Mileage, Features, Colours and other specs. MG Comet EV price starts at Rs 6.99 Lakh ex-showroom for Executive (Electric) and Tata Punch price starts Rs 6.13 Lakh ex-showroom for Pure (Petrol).
Comet EV Vs Punch
| Key Highlights | MG Comet EV | Tata Punch |
|---|---|---|
| On Road Price | Rs.9,78,557* | Rs.11,82,378* |
| Range (km) | 230 | - |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Petrol |
| Battery Capacity (kWh) | 17.3 | - |
| Charging Time | 7.5KW 3.5H(0-100%) | - |
Read MoreCollapse
MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch comparison
- VS
- Tata Punch
- Pure (Petrol) 6.13 Lakh*
- Pure Rhythm (Petrol) 6.38 Lakh*
- Adventure (Petrol) 7 Lakh*
- Adventure Rhythm (Petrol) 7.35 Lakh*
- Adventure AMT (Petrol) 7.60 Lakh*
- Accomplished (Petrol) 7.85 Lakh*
- Adventure Rhythm AMT (Petrol) 7.95 Lakh*
- Accomplished Dazzle (Petrol) 8.25 Lakh*
- Accomplished S (Petrol) 8.35 Lakh*
- Accomplished AMT (Petrol) 8.45 Lakh*
- Accomplished Dazzle S (Petrol) 8.75 Lakh*
- Accomplished Dazzle AMT (Petrol) 8.85 Lakh*
- Creative DT (Petrol) 8.85 Lakh*
- Accomplished S AMT (Petrol) 8.95 Lakh*
- Creative S DT (Petrol) 9.30 Lakh*
- Accomplished Dazzle S AMT (Petrol) 9.35 Lakh*
- Creative AMT DT (Petrol) 9.45 Lakh*
- Creative Flagship DT (Petrol) 9.60 Lakh*
- Creative S AMT DT (Petrol) 9.90 Lakh*
- Creative Flagship AMT DT (Petrol) 10.20 Lakh*
- Pure CNG (CNG) 7.23 Lakh*
- Adventure CNG (CNG) 7.95 Lakh*
- Adventure Rhythm CNG (CNG) 8.30 Lakh*
- Accomplished CNG (CNG) 8.95 Lakh*
- Accomplished Dazzle S CNG (CNG) 9.85 Lakh*
Rs10.20 LakhVS - Renault Kiger
- RXE (Petrol) 6 Lakh*
- RXL (Petrol) 6.60 Lakh*
- RXL AMT (Petrol) 7.10 Lakh*
- RXT (Petrol) 7.50 Lakh*
- RXT AMT (Petrol) 8 Lakh*
- RXT Opt (Petrol) 8 Lakh*
- RXT Opt DT (Petrol) 8.22 Lakh*
- RXT AMT Opt (Petrol) 8.50 Lakh*
- RXT AMT Opt DT (Petrol) 8.73 Lakh*
- RXZ (Petrol) 8.80 Lakh*
- RXZ DT (Petrol) 9.03 Lakh*
- RXT Opt Turbo (Petrol) 9.30 Lakh*
- RXZ AMT (Petrol) 9.30 Lakh*
- RXT Opt Turbo DT (Petrol) 9.53 Lakh*
- RXZ AMT DT (Petrol) 9.53 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo (Petrol) 10 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo DT (Petrol) 10.23 Lakh*
- RXT Opt Turbo CVT (Petrol) 10.30 Lakh*
- RXT Opt Turbo CVT DT (Petrol) 10.53 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo CVT (Petrol) 11 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo CVT DT (Petrol) 11.23 Lakh*
Rs9.30 Lakh
Basic Information
| On-Road Price in New Delhi | Rs.9,78,557* | Rs.11,82,378* | Rs.10,46,189* |
| Finance Available (EMI) | Rs.18,623/month | Rs.22,510/month | Rs.20,739/month |
| Insurance | Rs.38,757 Comet EV Insurance | Rs.50,289 Punch Insurance | Rs.39,300 Kiger Insurance |
| User Rating | |||
| Service Cost (Avg. of 5 years) | - | Rs.4,712 | - |
| Brochure | |||
| Running Cost Running cost per km measures the expense of driving your EV per kilometer. Running Cost/Km = (Battery Capacity of EV * Per Unit Electricity Cost ) / Range on full charge.✕ | ₹ 0.75/km | - | - |
Engine & Transmission
| Engine Type Engine type in car refers to the type of engine that powers the vehicle. There are many different types of car engines, but the most common are petrol (gasoline) and diesel engines✕ | Not applicable | 1.2 l Revotron Engine | 1.0L Turbo |
| Displacement (cc) The displacement of an engine is the total volume of all of the cylinders in the engine. Measured in cubic centimetres (cc)✕ | Not applicable | 1199 | 999 |
| No. of Cylinders ICE engines have one or more cylinders. More cylinders typically mean more smoothness and more power, but it also means more moving parts and less fuel efficiency.✕ | Not applicable | 3 3 Cylinder Cars | 3 3 Cylinder Cars |
| Fast Charging Fast charging typically refers to direct current (DC) charging from an EV charge station, and is generally quicker than AC charging. Not all fast chargers are equal, though, and this depends on their rated output.✕ | Yes | Not applicable | Not applicable |
View More View Less | |||
Fuel & Performance
| Fuel Type | Electric | Petrol | Petrol |
| Mileage ARAI (kmpl) | - | 18.8 | 19.17 |
| Fuel Tank Capacity (Litres) | - | 37 | 40 |
| Emission Norm Compliance Indicates the level of pollutants the car's engine emits, showing compliance with environmental regulations.✕ | ZEV | BS VI 2.0 | BS VI 2.0 |
View More View Less | |||
Suspension, Steering & Brakes
| Front Suspension The system of springs, shock absorbers, and linkages that connects the front wheels to the car body. Reduces jerks over bad surfaces and affects handling.✕ | McPherson Strut | Independent, Lower Wishbone, Mcpherson Strut With Coil Spring | MacPherson strut with lower transverse link |
| Rear Suspension The system of springs, shock absorbers, and linkages that connects the rear wheels to the car body. It impacts ride quality and stability.✕ | Multi-Link Coil Suspension | Semi-independent Twist Beam With Coil Spring And Shock Absorber | Twist beam suspension with coil spring |
| Steering Type The mechanism by which the car's steering operates, such as manual, power-assisted, or electric. It affecting driving ease.✕ | - | Electric | Electric |
| Steering Column The shaft that connects the steering wheel to the rest of the steering system to help maneouvre the car.✕ | Tilt | Tilt | Tilt |
View More View Less | |||
Dimensions & Capacity
| Length (mm) The distance from a car's front tip to the farthest point in the back.✕ | 2974 | 3827 | 3991 |
| Width (mm) The width of a car is the horizontal distance between the two outermost points of the car, typically measured at the widest point of the car, such as the wheel wells or the rearview mirrors✕ | 1505 | 1742 | 1750 |
| Height (mm) The height of a car is the vertical distance between the ground and the highest point of the car. It can decide how much space a car has along with it's body type and is also critical in determining it's ability to fit in smaller garages or parking spaces✕ | 1640 | 1615 | 1605 |
| Ground Clearance Unladen (mm) The laden ground clearance is the vertical distance between the ground and the lowest point of the car when the car is empty. More ground clearnace means when fully loaded your car won't scrape on tall speedbreakers, or broken roads.✕ | - | 187 | 205 |
View More View Less | |||
Comfort & Convenience
| Power Steering Mechanism that reduces the effort needed to operate the steering wheel. Offered in various types, including hydraulic and electric.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Power Windows Front Front windows that can be rolled up and down electronically. A must-have feature for modern-day cars.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Power Windows Rear Rear windows that can be rolled up and down electronically at the touch of a button.✕ | - | Yes | Yes |
| Automatic Climate Control Automatically adjusts the car’s cabin temperature. Removes the need to manually adjust car AC temperature every now and then & offers a set it and forget it convenience.✕ | - | Yes | Yes |
View More View Less | |||
Interior
| Tachometer A tachometer shows how fast the engine is running, measured in revolutions per minute (RPM). In a manual car, it helps the driver know when to shift gears.✕ | - | - | Yes |
| Electronic Multi Tripmeter Measures the distance a vehicle has travelled for a particular trip. A multi-tripmeter can keep track of multiple distances. For example kilometres since the last fuel up and kilometres travelled since the last service. The different tripmeters can be reset by the user as and when needed.✕ | - | Yes | - |
| Fabric Upholstery Seat coverings made from cloth. Affects comfort and interior style.✕ | - | Yes | - |
View More View Less | |||
Exterior
| Available Colors | Starry Black Aurora Silver Dual Tone Apple Green Starry Black Candy White Green Dual Tone Candy White Starry Black Comet EV Colors | Atomic Orange Calypso Red With White Roof Tropical Mist Meteor Bronze Carblu Pre With White Roof Daytona Grey With Black Roof Tropical Mist With Black Roof Orcus White Orcus White With Black Roof Tornado Blue With White Roof +3 MorePunch Colors | Ice Cool White Stealth Black Mahogany Brown Moonlight Silver Radiant Red Caspian Blue Kiger Colors |
| Body Type | Hatchback All Hatchback Cars | SUV All SUV Cars | SUV All SUV Cars |
| Adjustable Headlights | - | Yes | - |
View More View Less | |||
Safety
| Anti Lock Braking System A safety system that prevents a car's wheels from locking up during hard braking to maintain steering control.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Central Locking A system that locks or unlocks all of the car's doors simultaneously with the press of a button. A must-have feature in modern cars.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Child Safety Locks Safety locks located on the car's rear doors that, when engaged, allows the doors to be opened only from the outside. The idea is to stop the door from opening unintentionally.✕ | - | Yes | Yes |
| Anti Theft Alarm An alarm system that sounds when anyone tries to access the car forcibly or break into it.✕ | Yes | - | - |
View More View Less | |||
Advance Internet
| Live Location | Yes | - | - |
| Remote Immobiliser | Yes | - | - |
| Engine Start Alarm | Yes | - | - |
| Digital Car Key | Yes | - | - |
View More View Less | |||
Entertainment & Communication
| Radio AM/FM radio tuner for listening to broadcasts and music. Mainly used for listening to music and news when inside the car.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Speakers Front Sound system located near the dashboard or in the doors at the front of the car. ✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Speakers Rear Sound system speakers located at the back of the car. Usually found in the rear door panels or in the boot.✕ | - | Yes | Yes |
| Integrated 2DIN Audio | - | Yes | No |
View More View Less | |||
Newly launched car services!
Pros & Cons
- Pros
- Cons
- Small proportions, makes the car ideal for city use.
- Premium look and feel of the interiors
- Up to 250km of claimed range
- Highlight features include two 10.25 inch screens, Wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, connected car features, and keyless entry.
- Feels peppy and effortless to drive in the city
- Space for 4 adults
- Striking looks
- High quality cabin
- Great interior space and comfort
- Ride comfort over bad roads
- Mild off road capability
- 5-star Global NCAP safety rating
MG Comet EV
Tata Punch
- No boot space without folding the rear seats
- Ride comfort over bad roads
- Not at all a highway car, hence not an allrounder
- Engine feels short on power for highway drives
- Touchscreen interface could have been easier to use
- No charging port or cup holders for rear seat passengers
MG Comet EV
Tata Punch
Research more on Comet EV and Punch
- Expert Reviews
- Recent News
- Must Read Articles
MG Comet: Long Term Report (1,500km Update)
The MG Comet is a great urban mobility solution, but not one without a few drawbacks...
May 15, 2024 | By Ujjawall
MG Comet EV: Long-term Report (1,000 Km Update)
1000km in India’s most affordable electric car led to some new revelations about the Comet EV...
Apr 16, 2024 | By Ujjawall
MG Comet EV: Long-term Fleet Introduction
MG’s quirky little Comet EV gives life to the drives in and around the congested streets of Pune...
Jan 15, 2024 | By Ujjawall
Tata Altroz vs Punch vs Nexon: Space And Practicality Compared
Three Tata models, with completely different body styles, but a lot of commonality if you take a clo...
Mar 05, 2022 | By CarDekho
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite vs Renault Kiger: Space And Practicality Compared
The Punch is promising to offer the versatility and practicality of a sub-4 metre SUV in a shorter f...
Dec 29, 2021 | By Nabeel
Tata Punch: First Drive Review
With the Punch, Tata is trying to deliver a knockout blow to its competition. Have they succeeded?...
Oct 09, 2021 | By CarDekho
MG Brings British Racing Colours To Its India Lineup
The carmaker has launched a 100-Year Limited Edition for the Astor, Hector, Comet EV, and ZS EV...
May 10, 2024 | By Ansh
Watch: MG Comet EV Can Carry 5 Bags In The Back
While not false, it does change the purpose of the rear half of the cabin of the entry-level EV from...
Apr 29, 2024 | By Rohit
Tata Tiago EV Is Witnessing Higher Waiting Period Than MG Comet EV This April
The MG Comet EV not only boasts shorter waiting times but is also readily available in two cities...
Apr 09, 2024 | By Shreyash
New Maruti Swift 2024 vs Rivals: Price Comparison
How does the new Swift compare to the Grand i10 Nios, Punch and Triber in terms of prices? ...
May 10, 2024 | By Sonny
Tata Punch Is Top-Selling Car In India For Second Time In A Row
Demand for the Maruti Wagon R, Brezza, and Dzire jumped back up to their usual figures in April 2024...
May 07, 2024 | By Shreyash
Tata Nexon And Punch Were The Best-selling SUVs In India In FY23-24
This includes the EV versions of both SUVs, which have contributed over 10 percent to their respecti...
Apr 16, 2024 | By Rohit
Citroen C3 vs Tata Punch: Real-world Petrol-manual Fuel Efficiency Compared
We find out which of these unique rivals to conventional hatchbacks with similar performance is better for your fuel budget
Dec 19, 2022 | By Sonny
MG Comet: Long Term Report (1,500km Update)
The MG Comet is a great urban mobility solution, but not one without a few drawbacks
May 15, 2024 | By Ujjawall
Tata Punch: First Drive Review
With the Punch, Tata is trying to deliver a knockout blow to its competition. Have they succeeded?
Oct 09, 2021 | By CarDekho
Videos of MG Comet EV and Tata Punch
- 5:12MG Comet EV Vs Tata Tiago EV Vs Citroen eC3 | Price, Range, Features & More |Which Budget EV To Buy?10 months ago | 23.2K Views
- 14:47Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite vs Renault Kiger | पंच या sub-4 SUV? | Space And Practicality Compared2 years ago | 426.5K Views
- 8:22MG Comet EV Variants Explained: Pace, Play, And Plush | Price From Rs 7.98 Lakh | Cardekho.com11 months ago | 879 Views
- 4:54MG Comet: Pros, Cons Features & Should You Buy It?11 months ago | 21K Views
- 23:34MG Comet Detailed Review: Real World Range, Features And Comfort Review9 months ago | 52.1K Views
- 12:43Tata Punch - SUV Enough? Can it knock out competition? | First Drive Review | Powerdrift11 months ago | 55.1K Views
- 5:07Tata Punch Launch Date, Expected Price, Features and More! | सबके छक्के छुड़ा देगी?11 months ago | 199.5K Views
- 3:23Tata Punch Confirmed Details Out | What’s Hot, What’s Not? | ZigFF2 years ago | 12.7K Views
- 14:07MG Comet Drive To Death | Smallest EV Car Tested | ZigWheels.com9 months ago | 6.2K Views
- 2:31Tata Punch Crash Test Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | यहाँ भी SURPRISE है! | #in2mins11 months ago | 42.8K Views
Comet EV comparison with similar cars
Punch comparison with similar cars
Compare cars by Bodytype
- Hatchback
- SUV
Find the right car
- By Budget
- By Body Type
- By Fuel
- By Seating Capacity
- By Popular Brand
View MoreView Less
Questions & answers
- FAQ
Which car is cheaper between MG Comet EV and Tata Punch?
MG Comet EV price starts at ₹ 6.99 Lakh & Tata Punch price starts at ₹ 6.13 Lakh in New Delhi. Tata Punch is cheaper between these two cars.
*Ex-showroom price in New Delhi