Micra DCI K9K is better than Swift DDIS

By for Nissan Micra from chennai 2011-11-16 23:02:44.0
53 people found it helpful. 11342 ViewsWrite Review
4 ⁄ 5
  • Appearance
  • Performance
  • Comfort
  • Value For Money
  • Fuel Economy
  • Overall Satisfaction

Pros : mileage and space

Cons : Missing ABS and seat height adjustment

I own Cute Spring green Micra DCI XV. I want to share why I settled down with Micra DCI K9K over new Swift DDIS. Some may argue that Diesel car is economical only you run more than 2000 KM/per month. It is not true now. See the bellow calculation and you will understand why diesel car still economically even you are running 1200 K.M Petrol per litre Rs 72/- Mileage of petrol car(Example Micra Petrol) in city: 14 km/l running cost per km:  Rs 5.1 Total running cost for 1200 km : Rs 6171 Diesel per litre Rs 42/- Mileage of most efficient diesel ( Example Micra DCI ) car in city: 20 km/l running cost per km:  Rs 2.1 Total running cost for 1200 km : Rs 2520 Difference: Rs 3651/- Lets assume Diesel car 1 lakhs more than petrol car. The EMI difference due to cost difference is Rs 2150/- I.e within 27 months you will recover the additional cost you invested on Diesel car. Even before to it if the price difference between petrol and diesel goes up or running more than 1200 k.m per month. Let's talk about My Cute Micra DCI Pure Drive Exterior Really looks great in spring green. It is much better than any green color car ( Figo or Beat) in the market. Please google it and you know why I'm saying it. Nissan won color awards for their unique colors. Interior (Features, Space & Comfort) Nice and simple dash board, Decent Audio system, Very good FM Receiver, Nice , improved seats and head rest on rear seat on DCI pure drive model. Engine Performance, Fuel Economy and Gearbox The engine delivers both in terms of pickup and linear response. Those who worried about diesel car's clutch please forget about it. Its is almost like a petrol car. No turbo lag at all.  Less noise than Indica, Liva and Figo. Smooth gear shift and better millage than Indica. So far I’ve covered 1000 K.Ms both city and Highways. The onboard computer shows 22.3 KM/Litre. In city 19-20 KMs/L and Highways 22+ KMs/L with mix of AC turned on at NH and SH roads when driving at the speed of 80-90 KM/Hour.  It is good to have 80 KM/H at 2000 RPM. This is my second car. When I took the car from the showroom, odo meter was showing 60 kms and average mileage was 12 km/l. They told that it will increase steadily over covering 1000 k.m.  It is true. Now it was showing 22.3 k.m/l after covering 1000 kms and now it shows 22.1 after 1600KMs. The Maximum I reached was 22.7 KMs/l during long trip to Pondicherry at the speed of 80 KM/h. I also own Indica DLS and covered 82,000 KMs and I drove swift for 1000 K.M. The Micra's DCI engine is agile as Swift DDIS. Ride Quality & Handling  Easy to turn. Good at Highways too. Tilt steering allows to easy access of steering. Just keeping a finger on steering enough while driving in Highways. Deal breaker: What made me to settle with Micra over new Swift Initially I booked new swift ZDI on July 15 2011, a month before it was introduced in India.  Dealer informed that I was the second customer who booked that model and he promised me that I would be getting it in 30 days.  No one knows the exact cost of the car at that time and I was assuming it would be around 7.1 lakhs on road. I went to the showroom on the Aug 17 2011 to see it first time and it was priced at 7.48 lakhs. I liked the interiors and exteriors. I just sat on back seat and found that my head was just half inches bellow from the roof. Most of my family members are around 6 feet tall. I was little disappointed because after paying 7.5 lakhs, the rear passenger who is 6 feet tall should take care his head and neck while traveling on bumpy roads. I also felt little discomfort while entering and exiting the car compare to Micra. On the day they informed that I was 15th in the list of ZDI because who booked older Swift VDI had shifted to new ZDI model. So my waiting period entered into 2 month. Then I started looking for alternate diesel car. I did test driving on Figo TDI Titanium, Liva Petrol ( diesel was not available at that time) and Micra DCI. I felt better in Micra because of its space, ambiance, fit and finish inside the car. I can say Micra is best and Liva is worst.  One of my friend who was having Honda Civic informed that Micra’s DCI Engine is much better engine than Swifts DDIS (originally Fiat’s MultiJet). The fact is DCI K9K Engines sold more in numbers than DDIS/Multijet. It triggered me to do second test drive on Micra DCI and fell in love with Micra. I was double happy to book Micra because my daughter wanted a green color car which was not available in Swift. I was little skeptical about missing ABS even in higher version of Micra. In India 99% of the car ( also other vehicles) running without ABS. I’m going to stay in Chennai 95% of the days in a year. Final Words  Both engines are same in all aspects. DDIS is slightly quieter engine than DCI. Since Micra have better cabin insulation I hardly hear any noise. Compare to Swift VDI it is better VFM. Price difference between Swift VDI and Micra Diesel XV is less than Rs 15k. But you are getting Audio and Driver side SRS in Micra XV. It is worth it. Areas of improvement-Seat height adjustment missing (I’m 6.1 feet. It would be better if seat height adjustment is in place which will improve comfort level even better). ABS (it will be very helpful during panic braking on highways especially in wet surface).

Was this review useful to you? Yes 53   No 6
  • Don't miss out on the festive offers this December
Thanks For Voting
You have already recommended this review
  • Jessudass Vinodh |14 Dec,2011 02:45:48 PM

    Dear Prabhu, Good Comparison of Petrol and Diesel. Thanks for the wonderful blog. I too was calculating on that before upgrading my car. I had a Maruti Omni. I too love Micra, but unfortunately, there is no Dealer Network in Mysore. So, decided to turn for New Swift Vdi. The car is good and I enjoy the drive. I booked on April and was delivered on September. Wish you a Happy and Safe Driving. Jessudass.

  • sk |17 Jan,2012 06:47:15 PM


  • premjith |15 Feb,2012 07:15:19 PM

    Sir, what is the reason u said micra is best and Liva is worst? Liva is performing well in indian roads and is there any other comparison with nissan and toyota models. liva diesel milage and price also excellent compare to micra

    prabhu |31 Mar,2012 09:46:00 PM

    I said Liva worst interms of material used in it inside the cabin. One simple test 1: sit on the driver seat and just press root with you finger. Your finger will go inside paper like material. I test drove the pertrol version. I little more noise than other petrol cars.

  • premjith |15 Feb,2012 07:18:23 PM

    sir, U said micra is the best and Liva is the worst on what sense? Liva is more fuel efficient than micra and less in price. comfortness also in terms internal space is more.

  • Amit Mishra |26 Feb,2012 08:29:00 AM

    Hi, Referenece to Milage, are you still geting an average of 22.7KMPL on Actuals. I am having doubt that what you are vewing on display is not actual average of car. Please confirm.

    prabhu |31 Mar,2012 10:36:03 PM

    Yes. It is true. I measured it my calculating KMs given for Full Tank to Empty on Odo meter. On Highways: When speed is 75-85 KM/H then milage is 23 KMs/L When speed is 90-100 KM/H then milage is 21 KMs/L When speed is 100-120 KM/H then milage is 19-20 KMs/L Inside the city: 19-20 in avg traffic condition. I recently covered 10000 K.Ms in My Micra DCI. Cost for serice: Rs 3500/- ( for Engine OIL, Filters, etc) Rs 250 for vehicle pickup and drop at your door steps. Since the service station is 40 KMs from my home I went with Vehicle pickup option. I felt it is much convient than going for service station directly.

  • prabhu |31 Mar,2012 10:37:02 PM

    Yes. It is true. I measured it my calculating KMs given for Full Tank to Empty on Odo meter. On Highways: When speed is 75-85 KM/H then mileage is 23 KMs/L When speed is 90-100 KM/H then mileage is 21 KMs/L When speed is 100-120 KM/H then mileage is 19-20 KMs/L Inside the city: 19-20 in avg traffic condition. I recently covered 10000 K.Ms in My Micra DCI. Cost for service: Rs 3500/- ( for Engine OIL, Filters, etc) Rs 250 for vehicle pickup and drop at your door steps. Since the service station is 40 KMs from my home I went with Vehicle pickup option. I felt it is much convenient than going for service station directly.

  • AVINASH |06 Jun,2012 04:11:35 PM

    Highly appreciated Mr. Prabhu's Review. Very simple, elaborate and covering many aspects. I had test driven Micra XV in March 2011. That standing near the car time I had felt uneasy of engine sound. Then I have test driven other cars but somehow did not select any. Last fortnight I had tested Sunny XV. So Today 6th June 2012, I have again test driven Diesel Micra XV. When I read Prabhu's reviw I felt he was writing my review. I did feel same about lack of ABS but concluded not essential as I have been driving MATIZ for 12 years and Nano for 2 years without ABS. ABS good but not essential. Let prices be reasonable. I think it is fancy idea to add high price to differentiate between higher and lower version with ABS etc. Also I have not seen any SRS bags come in play ( saving passengers) in any accidents. At Goa car accidental deaths of drivers per year are rising. Regarding prices I have noticed the Goa dealer has quoted Ex Showroom price as in Delhi ( 5,96,408)where as it should have been Rs. 5,69,670 at Goa and Pune. Even Kolhapur price is 5,72,970. I request Mr. Prabhu, can you please or any one among the readers or from the CarDekho Team write or sms to me the latest price of Micra XV and XV Premium in Diesel /Petrol. Avinash Sonawane 09422438185 or email avinash@nio.org

  • sogith |08 Jun,2012 07:02:06 PM

    sir,i agree that micra is a good car.but not the best in class.just test ur micra by pushing it into a hard corner and then u wil come to know about the swifts stability also swift has got better breaking efficiency than the micra.plus swift always enjoys the benifit of good service netwok and resale value whic h I dont think u wil get i ur micra

    Kumar S |20 Dec,2013 09:58:23 PM

    There is braking issue in Swift at low speeds. There r lot of service center for muruti, but they also charging more for spare parts and services like imported cars. Micra's K9K engine almost having '0' turbo lag. Even Mercedes cars also using this K9K engine. You feel the power good in micra than swift when driving in city traffic and when overtaking at moderate speed. You feel he luxury when sitting in Micra.

Post a Comment
Your Name
Email Address
Mobile No
500 Characters Left
Indicator  Please Wait ...

Nissan Micra review scorecard

  • Over all
  • 6 Months
  • 3 Months


More reviews on Nissan Micra

Upcoming Nissan Cars

Nissan Micra similar cars to compare & consider

*Ex-showroom price New Delhi

Research On Nissan Micra

My Comparison

    Please tell us your city

    It will help us serve you better content and best deals

    eg. Mumbai, Gurgaon, Delhi