BMW X1 vs Kia Carnival Comparison

  • VS
    ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    BMW X1
    BMW X1
    sDrive20d xLine
    Rs44.50 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    Check May Offers
    VS
  • ×
    • Brand / Model
    • Variant
    Kia Carnival
    Kia Carnival
    Limousine Plus
    Rs34.99 Lakh*
    *Ex-showroom Price
    Check May Offers
  • sDrive20d xLine
    rs44.50 Lakh*
    Check May Offers
    VS
  • Limousine Plus
    rs34.99 Lakh*
    Check May Offers

BMW X1 vs Kia Carnival

Should you buy BMW X1 or Kia Carnival? Find out which car is best for you - compare the two models on the basis of their Price, Size, Space, Boot Space, Service cost, Mileage, Features, Colours and other specs. BMW X1 price starts at Rs 41.50 Lakh ex-showroom for sDrive20i SportX (Petrol) and Kia Carnival price starts Rs 29.99 Lakh ex-showroom for Prestige 6 STR (Diesel). X1 has 1998 cc (Petrol top model) engine, while Carnival has 2199 cc (Diesel top model) engine. As far as mileage is concerned, the X1 has a mileage of 19.62 kmpl (Diesel top model)> and the Carnival has a mileage of 14.11 kmpl (Diesel top model).

Read More...
Basic Information
Brand Name
On Road Price
Rs.47,30,438#
Rs.41,50,857#
Offers & Discount
1 Offer
View now
No
User Rating
4.5
Based on 39 Reviews
4.4
Based on 86 Reviews
Finance Available (EMI)
Rs.90,039
Check Now
Rs.80,920
Check Now
Insurance
Rs.1,04,264
X1 Insurance
Engine and Transmission
Engine Type
TwinPower Turbo 4-Cylinder engine
D2.2L VGT Diesel
Displacement (cc)
1995
2199
No Of Cylinder
Fast ChargingNo
-
Max Power (bhp@rpm)
187.74bhp@5000-6000rpm
197.26bhp@3800rpm
Max Torque (nm@rpm)
400nm@1750-2500rpm
440nm@1750-2750rpm
Valves Per Cylinder
4
4
Fuel Supply System
-
CRDi
Turbo Charger
Twin
Yes
Transmission Type
Automatic
Automatic
Gear Box
8-Speed
8-Speed
Mild HybridNo
-
Drive TypeNo
Clutch Type
Dual Clutch
No
Fuel & Performance
Fuel Type
Diesel
Diesel
Mileage (City)NoNo
Mileage (ARAI)
19.62 kmpl
14.11 kmpl
Fuel Tank Capacity
51.0 (Litres)
60.0 (Litres)
Emission Norm Compliance
BS VI
BS VI
Top Speed (Kmph)
222
No
Drag CoefficientNoNo

Add another car to comparison

  • Audi A4
    Audi A4
    Rs.40.49 - 48.99 Lakh *
  • Audi Q2
    Audi Q2
    Rs.34.99 - 48.89 Lakh *
  • BMW 2 Series
    BMW 2 Series
    Rs.41.50 - 44.50 Lakh *
  • BMW 3 Series
    BMW 3 Series
    Rs.46.90 - 65.90 Lakh *
  • Isuzu MU-X
    Isuzu MU-X
    Rs.35.00 - 37.90 Lakh *
Suspension, Steering & Brakes
Front Suspension
-
Macpherson Strut with coil spring
Rear Suspension
-
Multi Link
Steering Type
Power
-
Steering Column
Tilt & Telescopic
Tilt and Telescopic
Steering Gear Type
Rack & Pinion
-
Front Brake Type
Ventilated Disc
Disc
Rear Brake Type
Ventilated Disc
Disc
Top Speed (Kmph)
222
-
0-100kmph (Seconds)
7.9
-
Emission Norm Compliance
BS VI
BS VI
Tyre Size
225/55 R17
235/60 R18
Tyre Type
Runflat Tyres
Tubeless, Radial
Alloy Wheel Size
17
R18
Dimensions & Capacity
Length (mm)
4447
5115
Width (mm)
2060
1985
Height (mm)
1598
1755
Wheel Base (mm)
2670
3060
Front Tread (mm)
1561
-
Rear Tread (mm)
1562
-
Rear Headroom (mm)
1002
verified
-
Front Headroom (mm)
1065
verified
-
Front Shoulder Room (mm)
1440
verified
-
Rear Shoulder Room (mm)
1453
verified
-
Seating Capacity
5
7
Boot Space (Litres)
-
540
No. of Doors
5
5
Comfort & Convenience
Power SteeringYesYes
Power Windows FrontYesYes
Power Windows RearYesYes
Power BootYesYes
Automatic Climate ControlYes
3 Zone
Air Quality ControlYesYes
Remote Trunk OpenerNoYes
Remote Engine Start/StopNo
-
Low Fuel Warning LightYesYes
Accessory Power OutletYesYes
Trunk LightYesYes
Remote Horn & Light ControlNo
-
Vanity MirrorYesYes
Rear Reading LampYesYes
Rear Seat HeadrestYesYes
Adjustable HeadrestYesYes
Rear Seat Centre Arm RestYesYes
Height Adjustable Front Seat BeltsYesYes
Cup Holders FrontYesYes
Cup Holders RearYesYes
Rear AC VentsYes
-
Heated Seats FrontYes
-
Seat Lumbar SupportYesYes
Active Noise CancellationNo
-
Multifunction Steering WheelYesYes
Cruise ControlYesYes
Parking Sensors
Rear
Front & Rear
Navigation SystemYes
-
Find My Car LocationYes
-
Real-Time Vehicle TrackingYes
-
Foldable Rear Seat
-
60:40 Split
Smart Access Card EntryYesYes
Smart Key BandNo
-
Engine Start Stop ButtonYesYes
Glove Box CoolingYes
-
Bottle Holder
Front Door
Front & Rear Door
Voice ControlYesYes
Steering Wheel Gearshift PaddlesYes
-
USB Charger
Front
Front
Steering Mounted TripmeterNo
-
Central Console Armrest
With Storage
With Storage
Tailgate AjarYes
-
Hands-Free TailgateYesYes
Gear Shift IndicatorYes
-
Rear CurtainNoYes
Luggage Hook And NetNo
-
Lane Change IndicatorNo
-
Additional Features
Launch Control,Park Distance Control (PDC)
Rear Glass Tinted, UV Cut Front Door Glass and Windshield, Front Console Sunglass Case, Assist Grips, Get On/Off Grip, Coat Hook, LED Type Room lamp, LED Type Personal Lamp in 3rd Row, Conversation Mirror, Dr and Fr Passenger Extended Sunvisor with Vanity Mirror LED illumination included, Driver and Passenger Seatback pocket, 10 Way Power Driver Seat,Electric Parking Brake, 1st Row Passenger Sliding and Double Reclining Seats, 2nd Row Sliding and Double Reclining Seats, 2nd Row Headrest Wing out type, Auto Antiglare mirror (ECM) with Kia Connect controls,Diffused Rear Air Conditioner Vents, Cluster Ionizer, 2nd and 3rd Row Sunshade Curtains
Massage SeatsNo
-
Memory Function Seats
Front
-
One Touch Operating Power Window
Driver's Window
All
Drive Modes
3
-
Air ConditionerYesYes
HeaterYesYes
Adjustable SteeringYesYes
KeyLess EntryYesYes
Interior
TachometerYesYes
Electronic Multi TripmeterYesYes
Leather SeatsYesYes
Fabric UpholsteryNoNo
Leather Steering WheelYesYes
Leather Wrap Gear Shift SelectorYesYes
Glove CompartmentYesYes
Digital ClockYesYes
Outside Temperature DisplayYes
-
Cigarette LighterYes
-
Digital OdometerYesYes
Electric Adjustable Seats
Front
Front
Driving Experience Control EcoYes
-
Folding Table In The RearNo
-
Height Adjustable Driver SeatYesYes
Ventilated SeatsNoYes
Dual Tone DashboardYesYes
Additional Features
Micro-activated Carbon Particulate Filter for fresh and recirculated air,Ambient Lighting: Mood lighting in front and rear with 6 selectable light designs for instrument panel and door trims,Floor Mats in velour,Interior mirror with Automatic Anti-dazzle Function,Sport Leather Steering Wheel in Black with Black stitching and decorative finisher in Chrome,Panorama Glass Roof with automatic sliding/tilting function,Rear seat backrest adjustable in 2 tilt positions,Stainless Steel insert - in the loading edge cover of the luggage compartment,Storage Compartment Package,Instrument Cluster in Black Panel Technology with 5.7” (14.4 cm) TFT display including display of navigation arrows,Fine-wood trim ‘Fineline’ Stream with highlight trim finishers Pearl Chrome,Sensatec Oyster
Door Step Plate, SUS Type Door Scuff Plate, Wood Grain Door Upper Garnish, Chrome Inside door handle, LED High Mounted Stop Lamp, SUS Type Transverse Trim, Advance 3.5-8.89cm Display panel, Laptop Charger (220V)
Exterior
Available ColorsStorm Bay MetallicAlpine WhiteSunset OrangeMediterranean BlueSparking Brown MetallicBlack Sapphire+1 MoreX1 ColorsGlacier White PearlSteel SilverAurora Black PearlCarnival Colors
Body Type
Adjustable HeadlightsYesYes
Fog Lights FrontYesYes
Fog Lights RearYes
-
Power Adjustable Exterior Rear View MirrorYesYes
Manually Adjustable Ext Rear View MirrorNo
-
Electric Folding Rear View MirrorYesYes
Headlamp WashersYes
-
Rain Sensing WiperYes
-
Rear Window WiperYesYes
Rear Window WasherYesYes
Rear Window DefoggerYesYes
Wheel CoversNo
-
Alloy WheelsYesYes
Power AntennaNo
-
Tinted GlassNoYes
Rear SpoilerYesYes
Removable Or Convertible TopNo
-
Sun RoofYesYes
Moon RoofYesYes
Outside Rear View Mirror Turn IndicatorsYesYes
Integrated AntennaYesYes
Chrome GrilleYesYes
Chrome GarnishYesYes
Dual Tone Body ColourNo
-
Projector HeadlampsYesYes
Halogen HeadlampsNo
-
Cornering FoglampsNo
-
Roof RailYesYes
Lighting
LED Headlights,DRL's (Day Time Running Lights),Rain Sensing Driving Lights
Projector Fog Lamps
Trunk Opener
Smart
Smart
Heated Wing MirrorYes
-
LED DRLsYes
-
LED HeadlightsYesYes
LED TaillightsYesYes
LED Fog LampsYesYes
Additional Features
BMW Kidney Grille with exclusively designed vertical slats with front sides in Aluminium Matt, grille frame in Chrome High-Gloss,Front Bumper with sump guard and other design elements in Silver Matt,Side Sill Trim in Matt Silver,Door Sill insert in Aluminium with embossed designation,Sump guard in the back with main part in body colour and inset trim painted Silver,Aerodynamically optimised vehicle underbody - Front air guide and engine compartment shielding,Comfort Suspension,Sun Protection Glazing,Rain Sensor and automatic driving lights,LED Tail Lights with aerodynamicaly optimized 3D two-part L-Shaped design,Roof Rails in Aluminium Satinated finish,Twin exhaust tailpipe in Chrome finish,Wind deflectors on wheel arch, air curtain -specifically located air inlets in front bumper and air line through wheel arch for enhanced aerodynamics
R18-45.72cm (18") Sputtering Finish Alloy Wheels, Kia Signature Tiger nose grille with Chrome Inserts, Body Colour bumper and Outside mirror, Chrome Surround DLO, Rear Spoiler with LED HMSL, Front & Rear Skid Plates, LED Position Lamps, Chrome Outside Door Handles, Projector LED Type Headlamps with Escort and Anti-Fog Function
Tyre Size
225/55 R17
235/60 R18
Tyre Type
Runflat Tyres
Tubeless, Radial
Wheel Size
-
-
Alloy Wheel Size
17
R18
Safety
Anti Lock Braking SystemYesYes
Brake AssistYesYes
Central LockingYesYes
Power Door LocksYesYes
Child Safety LocksYesYes
Anti Theft AlarmYes
-
No Of Airbags
6
6
Driver AirbagYesYes
Passenger AirbagYesYes
Side Airbag FrontYesYes
Side Airbag RearNo
-
Day Night Rear View MirrorYes
Auto
Passenger Side Rear View MirrorYesYes
Halogen HeadlampsNo
-
Rear Seat BeltsYes
-
Seat Belt WarningYesYes
Door Ajar WarningYesYes
Side Impact BeamsYes
-
Front Impact BeamsYes
-
Traction ControlYes
-
Adjustable SeatsYesYes
Tyre Pressure MonitorYesYes
Vehicle Stability Control SystemYes
-
Engine ImmobilizerYesYes
Crash SensorYesYes
Centrally Mounted Fuel TankYes
-
Engine Check WarningYesYes
Automatic HeadlampsYesYes
EBDYesYes
Electronic Stability ControlYesYes
Advance Safety Features
Expert function for race track operation,Sporty, rapid gearshift timing in specific combinations of Driving Experience Control and gear selector switch,Engine control and brake interventions during cornering, agility enhancement and curve neutrality,Servotronic Steering Assist,Brake Energy Regeneration,Head airbags for the whole side window area,Electric Parking Brake,Analyses the driving behaviour of the driver,Suggests when to take a break in the control display,BMW Condition Based Service,Cornering Brake Control,Integrated Emergency Spare wheel,Runflat tyres with reinforced side walls,Warning triangle with first-aid kit,BMW ure Advance includes Tyres, Alloys, Engine ure, Key Lost Assistance and Golf Hole-in-One,Road Side Assistance 24x7
Roll Over Mitigation, Cornering Brake Control, Ice Cube LED Type Fog lamps, Burglar Alarm', Curtain Airbags
Follow Me Home HeadlampsYes
-
Rear CameraYesYes
Anti Theft DeviceYes
-
Anti Pinch Power Windows
Driver's Window
All
Speed AlertYes
-
Speed Sensing Auto Door LockYesYes
Knee AirbagsYes
-
Isofix Child Seat MountsYesYes
Heads Up DisplayNo
-
Pretensioners And Force Limiter SeatbeltsYesYes
Sos Emergency AssistanceNo
-
Blind Spot MonitorYes
-
Geo Fence AlertNo
-
Hill Descent ControlYes
-
Hill AssistYesYes
Impact Sensing Auto Door UnlockYes
-
Entertainment & Communication
Cd PlayerNo
-
Cd ChangerNo
-
Dvd PlayerNo
-
RadioYesYes
Audio System Remote ControlNo
-
Speakers FrontYesYes
Speakers RearYesYes
Integrated2DINAudioYesYes
Wireless Phone ChargingYesYes
USB And Auxiliary InputYes
-
Bluetooth ConnectivityYesYes
CompassNo
-
Touch ScreenYesYes
Touch Screen Size
8.8 Inch
8 Inch
Connectivity
Apple CarPlay
Android Auto,Apple CarPlay
Android AutoNoYes
Apple Car PlayYesYes
Internal StorageNo
-
Number Of Speaker
6
8
Rear Entertainment SystemNoYes
Additional Features
BMW Apps,Configurable user interface,iDrive Touch Controller
20.32cm (8") Touchscreen Infotainment System with In-Built Navigation (with OTA Map Updates), Harman/kardon premium 8-speaker Sound system (Acoustics by harman/kardon), Kia Connected Car, 25.65cm (10.1") Dual TouchScreen Rear Seat Entertainment
Warranty
Introduction DateNoNo
Warranty TimeNoNo
Warranty DistanceNoNo
Not Sure, Which car to buy?

Let us help you find the dream car

Pros and Cons

  • Pros
  • Cons

    BMW X1

    • Engaging drive experience
    • Diesel engine is super-refined
    • Ride quality is excellent over not so good roads.

    Kia Carnival

    • Most comfortable seats for the second and third row
    • Loaded with luxury features like rear touchscreens, dual sunroof and VIP seats.
    • Innovative boot space solutions
    • Lots of space inside the cabin

    BMW X1

    • Lack of features for its price
    • Steering wheel buttons feel tacky
    • Cost cutting is apparent in places

    Kia Carnival

    • Too big for regular parking lots. Longer than the Ford Endeavour
    • Ground clearance could limit use to city and well paved roads
    • 9-Seater configuration is too tight for 9 adults

Must read articles before buying BMW X1 and Kia Carnival

Videos of BMW X1 and Kia Carnival

  • 2020 BMW X1 Review: Barely Different? | ZigWheels.com
    8:32
    2020 BMW X1 Review: Barely Different? | ZigWheels.com
    Mar 05, 2020
  • Kia Carnival | The extra MPV | PowerDrift
    6:0
    Kia Carnival | The extra MPV | PowerDrift
    Jan 22, 2020

X1 Comparison with similar cars

Carnival Comparison with similar cars

Compare Cars By Bodytype

  • SUV
  • MUV

Research more on X1 and Carnival

  • Expert Reviews
  • Recent News
*Ex-showroom price in New Delhi
×
We need your city to customize your experience