Question & Answer

0 Shares
Ask a Question
Search for an Answer
Question

i am little bit confuse between ciaz and honda city ?? please share some info which would i will buy??

Published On : 2016-10-14 19:49:30.0 mihir
Answers for this Question

Maruti Ciaz vs Honda City

Styling:

Honda City retains a lot of styling from the previous generation and it is similar in length too. The Ciaz on the other hand is a lot more premium looking. The Ciaz because of its lower height and a bit longer. This makes it look a lot longer than the City. 

Honda City has trendy yet premium looking interiors. The black interiors with the piano black centre console looks stylish. There is a three spoke steering wheel with controls for audio and there are even cruise control buttons too. On the other hand, the interior styling of the Ciaz is a lot more subtle and feels more sophisticated. The black and beige interiors of this sedan makes it feel airy. The Ciaz SHVS has a simple dash with familiar Maruti steering wheel.

Engine Specifications:

Petrol : It's in the engines department where the City begins to pull away from the Ciaz, literally and figuratively. Honda's 1.5-litre i-VTEC engine is in a class of its own. It develops 119PS, a massive 27PS more than that of the 1.4-litre K-series petrol Ciaz's engine. The City petrol is also the freer revving unit till you reach a high 5000rpm when it begins to get coarse. The Ciaz on the other hand feels gruff above 2000rpm and short on legs in comparison. Even in gears, especially the higher ones, the City has considerably more punch, making overtaking and short bursts in power more enjoyable. In town lower down the rev band, both are easy to drive and it's where the Ciaz doesn't keep you wanting for more, but get on the open road at triple digit speeds and the Honda City is definitely the better pick. The City also has a slicker shifting gearbox too. There's nothing wrong with the Ciaz's with their short throws and smooth shifts but the City slots crisper shifts. 

Diesel: Honda has plonked in a more powerful engine than Maruti Suzuki. It is a lot more punchy and then you can drive it with ease. There is a lot of power at most of the engine speeds, which means you do not have to shift gears very often, be it in city or even the highway. This is one of the most strongest points of the Honda City.

This means better performance and fuel-efficiency too.

Talking of the numbers, City has a 1.5-litre i-DTEC (diesel) engine that chunks 98bhp of power and 200Nm of torque. This engine comes mated to a six-speed manual transmission. The gear lever is small and easy to shift.

The Ciaz SHVS on the other hand has a 1.3-litre diesel engine with SHVS technology. Now, this is the hybrid start stop system that even has brake regeneration. This is the same 1.3-litre engine that was there on the Ciaz. This hybrid system helps to improve the fuel-efficiency. The drivability of the Ciaz SHVS is good and is easy to drive in the city or even on the highway. This diesel engine comes with a five-speed manual transmission. 

Ride, handling and ease of driving: 

While the Ciaz has better ride, the City is a better handler. The Ciaz offers better grip though in tighter corners with its larger 195 section tyres where the City’s 175s begin to squeal sooner. The Ciaz is a better commuter and the City is more of an enthusiast’s pick overall.

Verdict:

It’s extremely hard to ignore the Maruti Ciaz, especially at this price. It comes with kitted all the bells and whistles and Maruti has done a fine job with its design, inside and out. The Ciaz is also very efficient and offers fantastic ride quality. It doesn't however impress with its engine. When you are paying close to a million rupees, you don't want your petrol car to do just one thing well, which is being a good city commuter. Here, the Honda City makes its case. It is acceptably efficient if you don't ask much from the engine and quick when you want to close that gap or munch those miles. It also handles better and pampers its occupants more. Maruti has a good package in the Ciaz but the Honda City is still overall the better deal.

Click here for detailed comparison. Do take a test drive before you make a final call. 
 

CarDekho Helpdesk on 2016-10-17 14:34:39.0
Post Your Answer
3000 Characters Left

Related Asked Questions

  • what is the difference between intellihybrid and microhybrid in scorpio ? which models of it feature cruise control?

    Published On :2017-05-21 22:13:23.0 suresh soni
    Thank you for showing trust in our services and writing to us. Apologies for the delay response. Mahindra Scorpio has a good road presence with aggressive styling. Talking about technology, Micro hybrid refers to the auto engine start/stop system alone. Intelli hybrid includes the engine start/stop and brake energy regeneration system that helps charge the battery (smart alternator) On the other hand, Intelli Hybrid S10 variant and above has cruise control feature loaded with it.
    1
    Answer
  • I have been using a Renault Duster RxL 4WD 2014 model since I bought it new in January 2015. I have clocked 60ooo Kms since and yesterday was shocked when I had a service charges bill for Rs 20,000. I had paid about Rs 18,000 when the car was serviced at 50,000 kms and in all I have paid more than Rs. 70,000 on service since purchasing this car. I am totally lost as to why Renault is charging such high prices for everything, when similar cars get serviced at less than a fourth of what I paid

    Published On :2017-05-25 11:57:52.0 Rajendran Koodali

    We are amazed to hear about your experience with Renault and we totally understand your concern about the maintenance of the car.

    In order to assist you in right direction, we recommend you to check the bill that was provided to you as it will be having all the charges that are made at the time of servicing of your car as it will clear all your doubts.

    On the other hand, for better clarification we suggest you to talk with service centre as they will be the right person to assist you with same.

    Click here to know an approximate idea of maintenance cost.

    These are estimated maintenance cost detail and cost may vary based on location and condition of car. Service Charge is not including any extra labour charges.

    1
    Answer
  • i want to buy hyundai xcent facelift car. i want to know its engine performance comparing to i20 elite engine. please guide me

    Published On :2017-05-22 23:11:20.0 By Arun

    Hey, its great that you are planning for a new car and Hyundai Xcent is indeed an amazing car. We must appreciate your choice. Hyundai has recently launched the facelift version of the Xcent which has gone through some cosmetic changes on the exteriors and interiors.

    Talking about the performance specifically, this car is being offered with 1.2 diesel and petrol engine. The petrol trim is capable of delivering a power of 84 bhp with a torque of 114 Nm whereas the diesel engine can deliver a power of 74 bhp with a torque of 190 nm.

    Talking about the mileage figures, the diesel motor delivers a maximum mileage of 25.4 kmpl (Highway) whereas the petrol motor delivers a maximum mileage of 20.14 kmpl (Highway).

    Now, there is no direct comparison between the performance between the performance of Hyundai Xcent and Elite i20 because of the engine difference. The petrol trim is same 1.2 liter engine but in diesel, the i20 comes with a 1.4 liter engine.

    Please click here to check the detailed review of Hyundai Xcent and you can also check the comparison between Hyundai Xcent and Elite i20 through here.

    1
    Answer
  • Our requirements are as follows: a. Budget of around 6.5 lakhs, Ex - Showroom price. a. Daily usage of 50-60 Kms. b. Good Leg Room (I

    Published On :2017-05-20 01:05:37.0 By Arun

    Thank you for showing the confidence and writing to us.

    There are ample of options available with the requirements you have listed. As you will be driving 50-60kms.(Approx) daily, we recommend you to opt for a diesel car.

    In Hatchback, options are Maruti Baleno, Hyundai Grand i10, Ford Figo etc.

    To begin with Compact Sedan options are Tata Tigor, Hyundai Xcent, Tata zest etc.

    Hatchback cars are easy to manoeuvre in bumper to bumper traffic conditions whereas sedans cars offers better luggage space and legroom.

    Click here to know more.

    Please find out input below:

    1. Maruti Baleno offers perfect balance of performance and features.

    2. On the other hand, Hyundai Grand i10 has spacious passenger and luggage space and is best suited for city.

    3. Ford Figo, a well-rounded product with 100PS diesel engine is fun to drive.

    4. Tata Tigor it has Multi Drive Mode: Eco & City which is just right for heavy city area.

    5. Tata Zest scored a respectable four-stars in the Global NCAP crash test.

    6. Hyundai Xcent offers better driveability with peppy diesel engine.

    Verdict:

    In you are looking for impressive feature list we suggest you to go for Tata Tigor or Hyundai Xcent. Otherwise, if you will be driving more on highways, we suggest you to go for Volkswagen Ameo or Tata Zest with better performance figures.

    Click here to check for detailed comparison and select the variant accordingly:

    You may also reach to us on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer
  • want to know Ameo petrol performance..???

    Published On :2017-05-20 15:22:11.0 PRALHAD

    Hey,

    We appreciate your interest towards car and your keenness to know the performance of VW Ameo. 

    Firstly talking about petrol variant, the petrol 1.2-litre is a tried and tested engine, 73bhp is what it produces and there's 110Nm of torque on offer and you might say the power is pretty sufficient for the segment. 

    About diesel, 1.5-litre, 4 cylinder diesel engine, which has been used in the Polo and the Vento, and it now makes its way into the Ameo. But what VW has managed to extract is more power out of this unit, which means that the Ameo is more powerful than the Polo. What Volkswagen has also managed to give the Ameo is a 5-speed manual and a 7-speed DSG. The 5-speed manual is a familiar unit and the gearshifts are smooth, which makes it a good companion, in both city traffic conditions and out on the highway.  

    Moreover, click here to read the "Volkswagen Ameo First Drive Review". 

    Click here to read the "Volkswagen Ameo Diesel: First Drive Review"

    1
    Answer

Advertisement

close

location

Please tell us your city

It will help us serve you better content and best deals

eg. Mumbai, Gurgaon, Delhi
My Comparison