Question & Answer

0 Shares
Question on your mind? Ask now!
Search for an Answer
Question

Hello,Can you please suggest the best car between Hyundai i10 Era, Hyundai i10 Magna 1.1L, Hyundai i10 Magna and Maruti A-Star Vxi, Maruti A-Star Zxi performance wise? I need the car mainly for city driving and occasional breaks on highways. Driving Comfort and I am 5ft 10 inches tall and Leg spacings are important for me. Rear leg spacing is also my concern somewhat as 2 - 3 persons will accompany me sometimes. I also consider cheap maintenance and readily available of spare parts. I don't want to stretch my budget beyond 4.5 lakhs. I will driving the car majorly in metros (Delhi NCR) and very rarely in Tier I and Tier II cities. I have also planned to use CNG in coming times as in the month my running distance varies grossly between 200 Km - 650 Km and rarely 1200 KM. Can you also suggest any other alternatives?

Published On : 2010-11-04 13:00:14.0 Subhajit Kumar
Answers for this Question
go by i10 megna
Dinesh Nathani on 2010-11-15 13:03:21.0
go by hyundai i10magna 1.2irde
mani.prk on 2010-11-14 16:24:38.0
why dOn't u try for ford figo
srsr on 2010-11-14 16:17:43.0
Thanks a lot I am buying Hyundai i10 magna.
Subhajit Kumar on 2010-11-13 18:00:39.0
Hi this is Ashok Yadav I will suggest u to go with hundai i 10 because the car feeling is in the hundai cars only,it is something special
Ashok Yadav on 2010-11-13 18:00:29.0
I would suggest go for New wagno r.
Sunilkumar on 2010-11-13 17:59:44.0
Don't Compaire with A Star i 10 is very nice car go by i10 megna 1.2 kappa2 only
Dinesh Nathani on 2010-11-13 17:59:27.0
i read all answers.. but my view is difrent.. you must go and drive chevrolet beat . i fully confidant that you will find your altimate car in form of beat.. price, value for money, millage, comfoet , power , space, style , solid, and sexi ... all in one.. that is beat... nothing ela...
mahendra pratap on 2010-11-13 17:59:16.0
I think that you can easily go for i10 and that too the SPORTZ version as u have mentioned your budjet between 4-5lacs.It will come in your budjet. and u know i10 is a very nice car with great handling and driving pleasure and ofcourse it will give a good mileage.i10 is far better than A-STAR. GO FOR i10
Vaibhava on 2010-11-13 17:58:28.0
Hi friend, these all we cant say cars,we can replace auto rikshaws by this.If you are looking for a good car just go for Toyota Innova or Maruti swit or RITZ.
dennis on 2010-11-13 17:57:55.0
i10 magna is great u can,t compare it with astar...........it is far far better than astar
jatin on 2010-11-13 17:57:34.0
Hi Subhajit,

The Magna is advanced variant of Hyundai i10 and has more features than Era, Magna is available with both both 1.1 and 1.2L petrol engine. The car is very fuel efficient and have good leg room for long persons. While Zxi is the top end variant of Maruti A-Star which has blessed with more features than Vxi, both the cars have same 1.2L petrol engine. This is reliable, very good performer, fuel efficient car. Spare parts are available anywhere in the market and maintenance is affordable. But let room is short than i10. Now you are the best judge.

For further details about the car please click on the given link in body text.

Thank you.
By Arun on 2010-11-13 17:57:29.0
go for Maruti A-star Zxi, compact, stylish,good mileage, comfortable, excelent performance.
Dr C.Vanlalhlua on 2010-11-12 18:31:38.0
if you want a reliable car go for toyota's and a good reliable car with low budget go for maruti's, we indian's go after false statements.
abhi on 2010-11-10 22:14:43.0
I suggest that you go for the new Wagon R CNG version. A very spacious car and you get a company fitted CNG kit too. It fits your budget too. And Maruti service and spare part availability is world renowned. Best of Luck
Naveen Nair on 2010-11-10 08:47:26.0
Pls note the Maruti A Star has a 998 cc engine and not a 1.2 engine as mentioned above
Vishwanathan on 2010-11-10 08:47:13.0
Post Your Answer
3000 Characters Left

Related Asked Questions

  • how can we change a folder in stereo while using pen drive

    Published On :2018-04-06 12:09:06.0 By Arun

    Thank you for trusting in our services & writing to us.

    CarDekho is the one-stop solution for your all needs related to cars.

    Every music system has different settings but generally it is the same as tuning radio station.

    Moreover, you can surf online for the same to have better clarification in this matter.

    Apologies for not being of much help here.

    1
    Answer
  • WISH TO BUY A NEW CAR BETWEEN Rs.8-0 --9 lacs whose handling

    Published On :2018-03-30 20:02:46.0 By Arun

    Thank you for considering us worthy enough to address your concern & writing to us.

    It's good to hear that you wish to buy a car & thank you for making us a part of it.

    There are ample of options available in different price range like Tata Tigor, Maruti Swift, Ford Aspire, Maruti Dzire, Hyundai Elite i20 etc.

    Click here - Cars in India Between Rs 5 Lakh to Rs 10 Lakh

    You may also apply filters to refine your search and can shortlist some of the options from the lot. Do let us know the hand-picked options so that we can help you to choose one.

    As new car purchase would depend on a lot of factors like budget, segment or brand preference, transmission, fuel type, specific feature requirement etc.
    Hence, we request you to share your inputs so that we can assist you in right direction.

    If you are traveling less than 50-60km a day, opt for a petrol car instead of a diesel. With the extra Rs 1-1.50 lakh spent on a diesel purchase, you can actually drive a similar petrol car for as many as two years! So, do your math carefully. A diesel usually makes sense if you are driving above 60/70km a day.

    Whereas, every one of us knows that traffic is becoming an ever increasing pain. It does not matter how quick your manual gearbox responds or how reliable it is when you get stuck in a huge traffic jam and suffer excruciating pain in your left leg constantly depressing the clutch.

    If you'll be driving more in heavy city traffic then we suggest you to opt for Automated Manual Transmission(AMT) which are easier to use and more comfortable for the driver, while Manual Transmission vehicles are less expensive more involved & are more fun to drive on highways.

    Moreover, we have a article for you which will help you in decision making.

    Click here - Upgrading Your Car? Check Out These Key Facts

    Moreover, to have the information on your finger-tips, you may also download our mobile application which is available on iOS and Android.

    You may also reach our auto-experts by calling on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer
  • Plz. sudggest BMW 320d or BMW X1

    Published On :2018-04-04 12:34:32.0 By Arun

    Thank you for showing confidence in our services & writing to us.

    Both the cars that you've selected are awesome and stack up against each other in certain ways.

    If you're looking for a chauffeur driven car and spending most of time on paved roads then BMW 3 series is the ideal choice. On the other hand, if you'll be tackling bad roads oftenly then we would suggest you to pick for BMW X1 as it excels in terms of ground clearance and have better off-road capabilities.

    Click here - BMW X1
    Click here - BMW 3 Series

    Click here - Compare BMW 3 Series and BMW X1 

    Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making a final call.

    Click here - Car dealers in India

    Our CarDekho app (available on iOS and Android) can churn out specific details at your fingertips. You can easily find in-depth car specification, pictures as well as reviews to help you narrow down your choice. Apart from this, you can also use our Feel The Car feature in the app which takes you through a virtual tour like never before.

    You may also reach our experts by calling on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer
  • IS THERE ANY POWER LAG PROBLEM IN MARTUTI S CROSS

    Published On :2018-03-12 13:43:15.0 By Arun

    Thank you for considering us worthy enough to address your concern & writing to us.

    It's good to hear that you wish to know about car & we'll be happy to assist you.

    Maruti S-Cross Highlights

    Maruti Suzuki S-Cross is amalgamation of two different body styles and it claims to provide the best of both worlds, i.e., luxurious sedan and rugged SUV. Exteriors of the S-Cross feature projector headlamps and the vertically slatted grille lends menacing character to the car. Maruti's SmartPlay infotainment system is the highlight of the S-Cross’s quality cabin and you will be pleasantly surprised with the plenty of cabin room. Boot is equally capacious and the best part is the sensible way it has been laid out to maximize the capacity.

    Under the hood, Maruti has employed Fiat-owned 1.3-liter multi-jet diesel engine (DDiS in Maruti Speak) putting out 90PS/200Nm. This gasoline engine now features the Suzuki’s smart hybrid system and comes mated to 5-speed manual gearbox.

    Click here - 2017 Maruti Suzuki S-Cross Facelift First Drive Review

    Performance

    While the 1.3-litre diesel engine in the S-Cross facelift delivers exactly the same power-torque figures as before, it is now paired with SHVS tech. Maruti Suzuki says that the addition of SHVS to the setup will aid fuel efficiency, but what’s immediately noticeable is the improved driveability at slow speeds. Where you would normally suffer from turbo-lag the torque assist feature of the smart hybrid system uses the electric motor to add some punch.

    The 1.3-litre engine can take the S-Cross into three digit speeds and cruise easily. However, it starts to feel strained when asked to make quick overtaking manoeuvers, even when it’s around the max torque range of 1750rpm. That’s when dropping a gear, or even two, is the only way out to pick pace. Once you go past 2500rpm, the S-Cross starts to pull neatly. Thankfully, gearshifts are smooth and sure slotting, and the clutch is light too.

    Click here - Maruti S-Cross Expert Review

    Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive in order to judge your driving comfort and performance.

    Click here - Car dealers in India

    Our CarDekho app (available on iOS and Android) can churn out specific details at your fingertips. You can easily find in-depth car specification, pictures as well as reviews to help you narrow down your choice. Apart from this, you can also use our Feel The Car feature in the app which takes you through a virtual tour like never before.

    You may also reach our experts by calling on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer
  • does ford ecosport titanium plus petrol comes in MT. and whether titanium petrol mt consists of reverse parking camera

    Published On :2018-03-10 18:46:25.0 By Arun

    Thank you for trusting in our services & writing to us.

    It's good to hear that you wish to know about car & we'll be glad to assist you.

    Ford EcoSport Highlights

    The Ford EcoSport comes with stylish exteriors, premium interiors, and a new 3-cylinder 1.5-liter petrol engine mated with a 6-speed automatic transmission. The 1.5-liter diesel motor has been carried over and claimed mileage figures for petrol manual, petrol automatic, and diesel manual are 17 kmpl, 14.8 kmpl, and 23 kmpl respectively.

    New EcoSport is available in total of 5 variants and the top of the line Titanium + trim comes loaded with features like six airbags, electronic stability control, ABS with EBD, traction control, large touchscreen infotainment system, projector headlamps, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, brake assist, and tyre pressure monitoring system.

    Ford Ecosport comes with the boot capacity of 352-litre and features 200 mm of ground clearance. In Indian market, 2017 EcoSport is up against the likes of Maruti Suzuki Vitara Brezza and Tata Nexon among others.

    Click here - 2017 Ford EcoSport First Drive Review

    Ford EcoSport Variants

    Ford’s compact SUV will be available in a total of five variants viz. Ambiente, Trend, Trend+, Titanium and Titanium+. While a manual transmission is available in all variants, the automatic will be available in the mid-spec Trend+ and the top-spec Titanium+ variants only.

    To know what each variant offers, click on the below link.

    Click here - Ford EcoSport Facelift: Variants Explained

    That said, Titanium comes with 2 options -

    1. 1.5 Petrol Titanium (Manual Transmission) not equipped with Rear Camera.
    2. 1.5 Petrol Titanium Plus AT (Automatic Transmission) equipped with Rear Camera.

    Our CarDekho app (available on iOS and Android) can churn out specific details at your fingertips. You can easily find in-depth car specification, pictures as well as reviews to help you narrow down your choice. Apart from this, you can also use our Feel The Car feature in the app which takes you through a virtual tour like never before.

    You may also reach our experts by calling on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer

Advertisement

close

location

Please tell us your city

It will help us serve you better content and best deals

eg. Mumbai, Gurgaon, Delhi
My Comparison