Question & Answer

0 Shares
Ask a Question
Search for an Answer
Question

Hello,Can you please suggest the best car between Hyundai i10 Era, Hyundai i10 Magna 1.1L, Hyundai i10 Magna and Maruti A-Star Vxi, Maruti A-Star Zxi performance wise? I need the car mainly for city driving and occasional breaks on highways. Driving Comfort and I am 5ft 10 inches tall and Leg spacings are important for me. Rear leg spacing is also my concern somewhat as 2 - 3 persons will accompany me sometimes. I also consider cheap maintenance and readily available of spare parts. I don't want to stretch my budget beyond 4.5 lakhs. I will driving the car majorly in metros (Delhi NCR) and very rarely in Tier I and Tier II cities. I have also planned to use CNG in coming times as in the month my running distance varies grossly between 200 Km - 650 Km and rarely 1200 KM. Can you also suggest any other alternatives?

Published On : 2010-11-04 13:00:14.0 Subhajit Kumar
Answers for this Question
go by i10 megna
Dinesh Nathani on 2010-11-15 13:03:21.0
go by hyundai i10magna 1.2irde
mani.prk on 2010-11-14 16:24:38.0
why dOn't u try for ford figo
srsr on 2010-11-14 16:17:43.0
Thanks a lot I am buying Hyundai i10 magna.
Subhajit Kumar on 2010-11-13 18:00:39.0
Hi this is Ashok Yadav I will suggest u to go with hundai i 10 because the car feeling is in the hundai cars only,it is something special
Ashok Yadav on 2010-11-13 18:00:29.0
I would suggest go for New wagno r.
Sunilkumar on 2010-11-13 17:59:44.0
Don't Compaire with A Star i 10 is very nice car go by i10 megna 1.2 kappa2 only
Dinesh Nathani on 2010-11-13 17:59:27.0
i read all answers.. but my view is difrent.. you must go and drive chevrolet beat . i fully confidant that you will find your altimate car in form of beat.. price, value for money, millage, comfoet , power , space, style , solid, and sexi ... all in one.. that is beat... nothing ela...
mahendra pratap on 2010-11-13 17:59:16.0
I think that you can easily go for i10 and that too the SPORTZ version as u have mentioned your budjet between 4-5lacs.It will come in your budjet. and u know i10 is a very nice car with great handling and driving pleasure and ofcourse it will give a good mileage.i10 is far better than A-STAR. GO FOR i10
Vaibhava on 2010-11-13 17:58:28.0
Hi friend, these all we cant say cars,we can replace auto rikshaws by this.If you are looking for a good car just go for Toyota Innova or Maruti swit or RITZ.
dennis on 2010-11-13 17:57:55.0
i10 magna is great u can,t compare it with astar...........it is far far better than astar
jatin on 2010-11-13 17:57:34.0
Hi Subhajit,

The Magna is advanced variant of Hyundai i10 and has more features than Era, Magna is available with both both 1.1 and 1.2L petrol engine. The car is very fuel efficient and have good leg room for long persons. While Zxi is the top end variant of Maruti A-Star which has blessed with more features than Vxi, both the cars have same 1.2L petrol engine. This is reliable, very good performer, fuel efficient car. Spare parts are available anywhere in the market and maintenance is affordable. But let room is short than i10. Now you are the best judge.

For further details about the car please click on the given link in body text.

Thank you.
By Arun on 2010-11-13 17:57:29.0
go for Maruti A-star Zxi, compact, stylish,good mileage, comfortable, excelent performance.
Dr C.Vanlalhlua on 2010-11-12 18:31:38.0
if you want a reliable car go for toyota's and a good reliable car with low budget go for maruti's, we indian's go after false statements.
abhi on 2010-11-10 22:14:43.0
I suggest that you go for the new Wagon R CNG version. A very spacious car and you get a company fitted CNG kit too. It fits your budget too. And Maruti service and spare part availability is world renowned. Best of Luck
Naveen Nair on 2010-11-10 08:47:26.0
Pls note the Maruti A Star has a 998 cc engine and not a 1.2 engine as mentioned above
Vishwanathan on 2010-11-10 08:47:13.0
Post Your Answer
3000 Characters Left

Related Asked Questions

  • SIR MY FORD FIGGO STREO NEED UNLOCK NUMBER?

    Published On :2017-07-27 20:49:46.0 By Arun
    0
    Answer
  • What is the function of Clutch lock system Bharath warangal

    Published On :2009-12-15 18:07:50.0 rajesh
    Walk towards the car when locked with the smart key in your pocket and the wing mirrors will automatically swing outward.
    4
    Answer
  • how is the mantanance

    Published On :2017-07-21 11:12:45.0 By Arun

    Thank you for trusting in our services and writing to us.

    CarDekho is the one-stop solution for your all needs related to cars.

    We're unable to understand your query here that which car service cost you wish to know about. Please share the name of the car or more inputs so that we can assist you accordingly.

    Moreover, to have the information on your finger-tips you can also download our mobile application which is available on Windows, iOS and Android.

    You may also reach to us on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer
  • Hello Mr Car Expert. Plz let me know about the performance and mileage of i-10 grand diesel version. pls tell me about the maintenance part.....whether it would require huge maintenance in diesel vehicles

    Published On :2017-07-19 16:42:17.0 sonu john

    Hey Mate,

    Thank you for showing trust in our services and writing to us.

    CarDekho is the one-stop solution for your all needs related to cars.

    Hyundai has launched the mid-life facelift of the popular Grand i10 hatchback in the country. It has spacious passenger and luggage space and is best suited for city. It has made significant changes; exterior design, equipment and even the engines have been tinkered with for that 'new-car' feeling.

    Click here - Hyundai Grand i10

    Talking about performance, the Grand i10 is offered with both petrol and diesel powertrains, the diesel motor was not the most powerful in the segment - the only downside in an otherwise brilliant package. It does have peppy diesel engine & extra torque helps it potter around town easily.

    Click here - Hyundai Grand i10 Expert Review

    As far as mileage is concerned, Grand i10 (diesel) has a mileage ranging between 21.0kmpl(city) and 24.0kmpl(highway). These are claimed mileage & will vary as per one's driving style.

    On the other hand, it is lighter on pocket i.e. easier to maintain.

    Click here - Hyundai Grand i10 service cost

    If you will be driving around 50-70kms.(Approx.) a day, we will suggest you to go with diesel variant. Otherwise, if your driving will be less, than you can opt for petrol variant.

    Moreover, to have the information on your finger-tips you can also download our mobile application which is available on Windows, iOS and Android.

    You may also reach to us on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer
  • which car is VALUE FOR MONEY HONDA CITY MARUTI CIAZ TOYOTA PLATINUM ETIOS

    Published On :2017-07-17 16:59:26.0 By Arun

    Thank you for trusting in our services & writing to us.

    All the options you've selected are awesome & stand apart in their own way.

    Honda City both engines are very fuel-efficient and are easy to drive in the city and also offers Dual-airbags, ABS with EBD as standard safety features.

    Click here - Honda City

    Maruti Ciaz is a comfortable, value for money sedan. It is a mild hybrid car and first in it's segment which makes the claimed mileage figures possible.

    Click here - Maruti Ciaz

    The Platinum Etios is powered by a 1.4-litre diesel (68PS, 170Nm) and a 1.5-litre petrol (90PS, 132Nm), with both engines mated to a 5-speed manual transmission. However, the updated Etios comes with improved ride and handling over the previous model.

    Click here - Toyota Platinum Etios

    Verdict:

    Here, if you're looking for better mileage figures & pocket friendly car then we suggest you to opt for Maruti Ciaz. Rest, you may opt for Honda City which is a great all-rounder.

    The long-term maintenance of Toyota Platinum Etios is low & has Toyota aspirational value associated with it.

    Click here - Compare Honda City and Maruti Ciaz and Toyota Platinum Etios

    If you will be driving around 50-70kms.(Approx.) a day, we will suggest you to go with diesel car. Otherwise, if your driving will be less, than you can opt for petrol car.

    Moreover, to have the information on your finger-tips you can also download our mobile application which is available on Windows, iOS and Android.

    You may also reach to us on our toll free number i.e. 1800-200-3000 from Mon-Fri (10 AM - 7 PM) or write to us at support@cardekho.com. Our team will be more than happy to help you.

    1
    Answer

Advertisement

close

location

Please tell us your city

It will help us serve you better content and best deals

eg. Mumbai, Gurgaon, Delhi
My Comparison